Ranking the Analysts

Posted in: Newsletter articles on May 23, 2019


While the Financial Mail rankings represent the views of asset managers and other institutions in SA, the Extel rankings are based on the opinions of institutional investors in the rest of the world. You will be able to see both in the magazine next week in one package.

As South Africa’s capital markets have become increasingly traded by foreign investors, their opinions have become more important. Many South African-based brokers target a worldwide customer base.

The Extel survey assesses teams for their coverage of SA, rather than individual analysts as the FM rankings do. The Extel results are derived from an online survey conducted in March and April covering asset managers in approximately 55 countries. The FM rankings are based on a survey of 40 institutions, but the feedback is broken down into 40 different research sectors, ranging from large cap equity analysis to analysis of derivatives and risk management. The FM’s firm rankings are then based on a weighted addition of each research sector. Read more on Extel’s role here

Have your say.
Share your opinion

RELATED ARTICLES

PETER ATTARD MONTALTO: So much need for stimulus, so little room to move

March 16, 2020

The government has not set aside enough funds for a rainy day, and coronavirus now adds severe external shocks This column was first published in […] read more

STUART THEOBALD: Politics is the stick in the wheel of shares

March 9, 2020

Unfortunately, politics is what share prices now depend on. read more

PETER ATTARD MONTALTO: Backlash against Mboweni is based on misconception of his powers

March 2, 2020

Misconceptions overestimate and underestimate the finance minister’s powers read more