Intellidex’s Top Private Banks and Wealth Managers survey is a major annual project to assess firms in the wealth management and private banking market.
Launched in 2012, Intellidex conducts this annual survey to determine the top players in various categories of the wealth management and private banking sectors. Participating firms complete a questionnaire and a major survey of their clients also informs the rankings.
Intellidex provides consulting services to firms drawing on the extensive insights we gain into the market through the research project. The results of the research are published in partnership with media houses, but extensive additional information is used to assist firms to develop insights into their clients and market places.
PSG Wealth and NFB Financial Services are the two overall winners in the 2019 Intellidex Investors Monthly Top Private Banks & Wealth Managers awards.
The survey finds that clients are becoming increasingly concerned at the state of the economy and the erosion of the value of their assets. At the same time, they express high levels of confidence, trust and even admiration for the people who are managing their wealth.
PSG received its award as the top wealth manager in the category for large financial institutions at a ceremony in Johannesburg last night. It also wins in two archetype categories: young professional and successful entrepreneur.
NFB is the top boutique wealth manager of the year and also wins in the passive lump-sum investor archetype. The firm is also the People’s Choice winner as top wealth manager, which is voted for by clients.
The top private bank award was won by Investec Private Bank, which also scooped the People’s Choice award in that category.
This year Intellidex introduced a new award for the country’s top individual wealth manager. Nominees were selected from motivations made by their clients. The 2019 Top Financial Advisor is awarded to Sonia du Plessis from Brenthurst Wealth.
The full results and survey report are published in the Investors Monthly magazine distributed with this week’s Financial Mail.
Click here for our 2019 survey report.
The project was first undertaken in 2012 based on a questionnaire of institutions operating in the industry. In 2013 a major client survey was added. Below is an outline of the methodology as deployed in 2019.
If you would like your firm to be included in the survey, contact Colin Anthony at firstname.lastname@example.org or call 010 072 0472
Two-pronged research process
Our research process has two main elements.
The first is a comprehensive questionnaire that the firms complete. The main part of this are typical client archetypes for which we ask the firms to develop a service proposal. The intention is to clarify just what areas of the market the firms specialise in and their own capabilities. The archetypes are: the passive lump-sum investor; the up-and-coming professional; the successful entrepreneur; the wealthy executive; and the internationally wealthy family. We also interrogate the decision-making processes at the firms and their costs, and obtain details about staffing levels, offices and the size of the businesses. The responses to that questionnaire form the core part of the scoring process undertaken by the judges.
The second prong is the online client survey from which the People’s Choice award is determined. The questions are wide-ranging and designed to assess the different strengths and weaknesses of the private banks and wealth managers. The main areas of focus, though, are on satisfaction levels with products and services, and whether clients believe they are getting value for money, for fees charged. We also ask questions relating to why clients use private banks and wealth managers and whether their specific needs are being met. Clients also add comments on aspects not covered by our multiple-choice format of questions. Here we received some valuable insights and these were used to inform the judging process.
In terms of the overall judging, we understand that firms have different areas of focus. Thus, in our minds, the individual archetype winners are at least as important as the overall awards. If a firm is the best in the industry in its specific area of focus and does not pretend to be all things to all people, it deserves recognition for that area of excellence. If a firm does not compete in a particular market segment, we do not penalise it for not having an offering for that archetype.
However, the nature of such a survey does reward the all-rounder – those firms with comprehensive offerings across all categories – when it comes to the overall award. That is one of the reasons that last year we revised the format of the awards: we no longer split private banks (firms with transactional banking) from wealth managers in all categories. We thus have one overall winner, the best wealth manager, with two supplementary awards – Top Wealth Management Boutique and Top Banking Services Firm – to recognise other segments. We also acknowledge the best institutions for five different client archetypes with individual awards.
The first round of assessment involves each judge scoring each firm separately for each archetype. Under the judging guidelines, we’ve tried to make this phase as quantitative as possible, though a subjective element is unavoidable. In the second phase, scores are compared and “outlier” scores are discussed. So, if three judges gave a firm good scores but one scored it very badly, it will be interrogated. Next we tackle the tiebreakers. When firms receive equal scores in a category, judges go through each submission again, assessing strengths and weaknesses, to determine which will be the winner.
In determining overall rankings, we average the scores from each judge per archetype and weight them according to the client segment breakdown provided by each firm.
The 2019 Top Private Banks and Wealth Managers will be published on 27 June in Financial Mail Investors Monthly with iress as the Gold Sponsor and Satrix as the Event Sponsor on 25 June 2019.